Substance vs. Form
Tuesday, May 7th, 2013Symbolism is nice; substance is better.
-I.M. Windee
Symbolism is nice; substance is better.
-I.M. Windee
Over the coming days, weeks and months, society will try to understand, explain and rationalize the murderous atrocities that the Tsarnaev boys committed in Boston.
It’s fine if we try to figure out what reasonable safeguards, if any, society can implement to prevent such barbaric catastrophes.
In the Old West, evil got its due with no rationalizing
________________________________________
But it is critical that in trying to find an explanation for why people resort to such violence, we do not conclude that their acts, and similar ones that occur throughout the world every day, are somehow justified and rational acts. They are nothing more than pure evil, whether motivated by a conscious decision to do wrong to advance an agenda (“we’ll bomb them into political submission”) or the inability to decipher right from wrong (“the dog made me do it”). When all is said and done, there is no mathematical formula, algorithm, arc of the covenant or the like that can explain let alone justify murder as being anything other than a wrong that is unacceptable to civilization.
Moral relativists are, at best, confused when they equate bombers who detonate themselves in crowds of civilians with the minutemen of our American revolution or similar patriots of revolutions that fought for the dignity and freedoms that rightfully belong to human beings. At their worst, such apologists are aiding and abetting, if not instigating, such barbarism.
Such exercise in moral relativism occurred right after the Boston bombings when Richard Falk, a special rapporteur of the United Nations Human Rights Council and professor emeritus at Princeton, wrote a ridiculous diatribe blaming the “American global domination project” for terrorism. Sadly, he is not alone in the halls of academia and elsewhere.
Given the clear-cut wrongness of terrorist acts and the existential threat they present to a forward-moving civilization, the perpetrators, whether they be those who carry out the actual acts or instigate them from a mosque, an ostensibly god-fearing church or a KKK hall, must be shown the gallows post-haste, lest there be no one left but them.
I.M. Windee
Civil War hero Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain commanded a Union regiment at the Battle of Gettysburg. Out of ammunition and in a state of desperation while defending a critical hill that, if taken by the Confederates would’ve exposed the entire Union army to destruction, he ordered one of the most brutal military actions: a bayonet charge. The day and arguably the ultimate Union victory was saved.
The following is a portion of his recount of that 90 minutes in a letter he wrote 4 days later. Inserted in [BOLD LETTERING] is this father’s recount of a similar recent battle with his 8 and 10 year olds:
The struggle of an hour & a half [MOST OF THE DAY SINCE THE CRUMB-CRUNCHERS WOKE UP] was desperate in the extreme [SEEMINGLY HOPELESS AT TIMES]: four times did we lose & win that space of ten yards between the contending lines, which was strewn with dead and dying [COUNTLESS TIMES DID I TAKE AND RE-TAKE THE DEN AND KITCHEN, WHICH WAS LITTERED WITH TOYS, BROKEN ITEMS AND WHAT APPEARED TO HAVE BEEN AT SOME POINT EDIBLE FOOD, ALTHOUGH TOO MUTILATED TO TELL]. I repeatedly sent to the rear reports of my condition [I INFORMED MY WIFE OF THE IMINENT DESTRUCTION OF THE HOUSE], that my ammunition was exhausted [MY PATIENCE WAS RUNNING OUT], & that I could hold the position but a few minutes longer [I WAS ABOUT TO LOSE MY SANITY].

Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain & I.M. Windee:
2 battle-hardened veterans
________________________________________________________________
………In the midst of this, our ammunition utterly failed [MY WIFE’S ADVICE TO REASON WITH THEM IN THE SPIRIT OF MODERN PARENTING WAS MET WITH SNEERING CONTEMPT AND DISREGARD BY THE KIDS]……..Officers came to me, shouting that we were “annihilated” [MY WIFE AND I CONCLUDED THE BATTLE WAS BEING LOST]…..I saw that the defensive could not be maintained not an instant longer [I HAD TO CHANGE MY TACTICS IMMEDIATELY OR THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP WOULD BE LOST FOREVER], & with a few gallant officers rallied the line, ordered “bayonets fixed,” & “forward” on the run. My men went down upon the enemy with a wild shout [REALIZING THERE WAS NOTHING LEFT TO LOSE, I FIXED THE PARENTAL BAYONET (AN EXTENDED HAND IN THE SPANKING POSITION) AND WITH A GUTTERAL, DEMONIC SHOUT, SWEPT FORWARD INTO THE DEN]…the rebels seemed so petrified with astonishment that their front line scarcely offered to run or fire [IN WHAT HAD TO BE IMMEDIATE INCONTINENCE ON MY KIDS PART, THEY BROKE AND RAN, WITH A PETRIFIED LOOK, THROUGH THE KITCHEN, DINING ROOM, LIVING ROOM AND UP THE STAIRS TO THEIR RESPECTIVE REDOUBTS (BEDROOMS). NOT A HAND WAS LAID. THEREAFTER, THEY CAME OUT OF THEIR ROOMS WITH THE OFFER TO CLEAN THE CARNAGE THEY HAD CAUSED. ORDER HAD FALLEN UPON THE HOUSE (AND HAS LASTED SINCE). THAT NIGHT, GIVEN THE UNUSUALLY CHILLY WEATHER FOR LATE SPRING, THE VICTORIOUS PARENT CHOSE TO REFLECT ON THE DAY’S BATTLE OVER A CAMPSIDE FIRE IN THE SAME WAY AS DONE AFTER BATTLES PAST. THE FIREPLACE WAS FED MODERN PARENTING BOOKS, WITH NO REGRETS].
-I.M. Windee
*****************************************************************************
An accountant recalls (non-Kodak) memories from another tax season
*****************************************************************************
As another tax season came to a close, some memories:
Recounting another tax season
______________________________________________
-I.M. Windee
*****************************************************************************
The Beatles, no Conservatives, didn’t like high taxes
*****************************************************************************
With the tax deadline tomorrow and a never-ending debate on taxation that goes back at least to the Roman Empire, it might be instructive to consider The Beatles’ position on taxes as expressed by the lyrics of their song Taxman:
Let me tell you how it will be
There’s one for you, nineteen for me
‘Cos I’m the taxman
Yeah, I’m the taxman
Should five percent appear too small
Be thankful I don’t take it all
‘Cos I’m the taxman
Yeah, I’m the taxman
If you drive a car, I’ll tax the street
If you try to sit, I’ll tax your seat
If you get too cold, I’ll tax the heat
If you take a walk, I’ll tax your feet
Taxman
‘Cos I’m the taxman
Yeah, I’m the taxman
Don’t ask me what I want it for
(taxman Mr. Wilson)
If you don’t want to pay some more
(Taxman Mr. Heath)
‘Cos I’m the taxman
Yeah, I’m the taxman
Now my advice for those who die
Declare the pennies on your eyes
‘Cos I’m the taxman
Yeah, I’m the taxman
And you’re working for no one but me
Taxman.
-I.M. Windee
*****************************************************************************
The voice of youth is fine, so long as it knows what it’s talking about
*****************************************************************************
Up until the 1950s, the voices of youth were generally not given much credence, if heard at all. Then came the “Beat Generation.” as coined by Jack Kerouac, where youth was seen as a semi-rebellious movement, as personified by James Dean. But then the voice of youth (anyone under 30 to borrow their definition from the children of the 60s) came into bloom in the 1960s where teenagers and those in their 20s protested everything from social injustice (which in their view included the illegalization of drugs) to the Vietnam war.
It’s tough to say what impact the protesters had in ending the Vietnam war but it ended sooner than had they not publicly weighed in like they did.
But since the 1960s, youth has still been speaking far louder than before it. And on complex topics like global warming and economics.
Recently, there I looked at a picture (below) of Cypriot students protest the bailout package that the European Union was giving to 2 of the largest banks in Cyprus. I wondered how many of them knew about the underlying mechanics of the crisis. And how much did they know about banking? If even a handful of them had any material assets of significantly greater value than their I-Whatevers, that would be a surprise. Most likely they did not have deposits in the failed banks being rescued. In short, they probably had little if any immediate skin in the game, let alone knowledge on the matter.
Associated Press
Cypriot students protest the bailout package in Nicosia, March 26.
_________________________________________________________________
But from a long-term perspective, they unknowingly put quite a few chips on the table. By advocating yet another ostensibly painless government bailout, they were only advocating piling on even more debt and burden onto themselves and generations yet born. How many of them will support an endlessly growing government-state when they become taxpayers.
This has become the common thinking: assume that somehow The Great Oz (government) will resolve all problems. Any social, economic, environmental or other problem can be solved by government and whenever there is the slightest bit of pain inflicted on private parties for their malfeasance or just plain lousy judgment, it is because government has not come to the rescue enough.
Perhaps more than even during the Great Depression, all too many people believe that government is a panacea for all of the world’s ills.
The problem with this anti-physics thinking is that, ultimately, government solutions must be paid for, as government merely transfers and does not create wealth. Thus, government is solving a problem with other people’s resources. So who specifically must pay for the government solutions? Future generations, whether they be in the private sector or choose the refuge from reality that all too much of government employment is.
Perhaps all students should take an obligatory course in physics and learn one of its basic tenets: to give to one thing you must take from another.
-I.M. Windee
*****************************************************************************
The mutually-exclusive position of bemoaning wealth-creation but insisting upon more people on Mother Earth
*****************************************************************************
In Pope Francis’ Easter message, he bemoaned a world “torn apart by…….the iniquitous exploitation of natural resources!” He went on to hope that humanity becomes “responsible guardians of creation.” Presumably he was referring to the elimination of abortion, a very worthy and necessary goal. It would be nice, though, if the church would add birth-control to its definition of responsible guardians of creation but that’s a discussion for another day.
Perhaps the Vatican takes a green position in the hopes of increasing its fan base, and thus what it pulls into the collection plate. But in all likelihood, it is more the byproduct of a purist and idealist, if not naive, view of how humanity should conduct itself in this world.
Pope Francis deplores materialism…..unless it fills the collection basket
_____________________________________________________
The great irony, though, of the pope’s denunciation of the exploitation of natural resources, iniquitous or otherwise, is the seeming ignorance of the fact that wealth creation, which includes exploiting natural resources, is what fills the never-ending collection plates in churches. Without those evil capitalists obsessed with materialism, institutions in formal education, public broadcasting and organized religion, which natively distance themselves from the evils of money but can never stop asking for such, would cease to exist. And the church’s position that birth-control should not be used which would result in an explosion in population is inconsistent with the discouraging of wealth creation that occurs when natural resources are exploited, as one could argue God meant them to be.
Pope Francis has inherited many challenges that the church faces, much of which stem from a loss of spiritualism amongst its flock. But one area that the church could help re-connect itself with its members is realizing, accepting and admitting that wealth, while in and of itself not redemption, can address people’s basic needs and allow them to elevate themselves to be better pilgrims, which is what the church always calls for.
As this new pope is partial to calling for tolerance, he may want to consider the tolerance of those people and acts, despite their materialistic tinge, that allow us to meet basic needs and consequently think at a more spiritual level.
-I.M. Windee
[THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
-I.M. Windee
*****************************************************************************
An imperfect system of governing (and citizen mindset) doesn’t force the wisdom of Obama on us
*****************************************************************************
When it comes to the mindset of President Obama, everything revolves around government and government has all of the solutions, if we just have the good sense to let it address our problems. To our president, a society is judged, and problems solved, by its government and not its people. This despite whatever perfunctory remarks he may make on the campaign trail or elsewhere about individualism and the right of people to run their own lives. In fact, in a moment of candor, Mr. Obama likely would wonder why the pilgrims who came ashore in the early 1500s did not immediately establish a large entitlement state run by government. Surely that would have alleviated the high mortality rate they experienced in the first years here.
And anyone who disagrees with his government-centric view of the world is either malevolent (Conservatives/Republicans) or not evolved (the large groups of polled people who think government spending is out of control). So these people are to be ignored and the policy juggernaut of ever-growing government must proceed unabated. Eventually, when force-fed socialism a la Europe, people will fall into an msg-like acquiescence and accept, even if just in a daze, that government is the only answer. Orwell could not have scripted this reality better or more believably in a novel.
11th Century Hawaiian King Canute showed the limits of his power; President Obama believes his powers are limitless
_______________________________________________________
But the president’s critics gets it wrong when they suggest that Mr. Obama is not to be trusted as John Boehner and Republicans generally don’t believe Mr. Obama.
The mindset of the president seems to be one of an infallible and absolute ruler, not necessarily that of someone intentionally duplicitous. In his view, it is the imperfection of our system that he is not allowed to impose his will and polices on this country without question. This is evidenced by his actions after the election in which he by no means won a convincing mandate but he and his Liberal wingmen acted as though they not only won a landslide of FDR or Nixon proportions but that the election also changed the constitution and vested in him absolute authority to impose his will. If the Republicans in the House did not go along, it was only because they were tone-deaf to this high-pitched whistle that only Liberals could somehow discern. Nonetheless, Liberals believe Republicans should rubber-stamp his agenda and how dare they if they don’t!
And where did he get such a belief that he should be completely deferred to? Predominantly by defeating the Clinton machine.
A mere 5 years ago, Mr. Obama was a long-shot taking on one of the best political machines known to history: the Clintons. Going into 2008, few people who followed politics really believed that the rookie senator from Illinois was any match for Arkansas’ national political version of Bonnie & Clyde. After so effectively dispatching their adversaries in the 1990s, Hillary (and Bill [“2 for the price of 1”]) would easily win the 2008 Democratic nomination. But with an effective grass-roots campaign as well as an electorate weary of insiders given the financial meltdown, Mr. Obama capitalized on his luck and the pupil taught the teacher (to this day, no one, including Republicans, is more amazed and flummoxed at Mr. Obama’s ascension than Bill and Hillary Clinton). Thus, in President Obama’s belief, he has earned the right by virtue of his Herculean electoral accomplishments to get what he wants, despite what pesky documents like the Constitution say.
As the never-ending sequester talks drag on, Speaker Boehner and Republicans would do well to realize that they are dealing with a take no prisoners politician in the president. He will only respond (and compromise in fact and not just word) when he is faced with political defeat or the threat thereof.
-I.M. Windee
follow: